Lesson 8:

Gold and Fiscal Policy

Lesson 8:

Gold and Fiscal Policy

There is always a lot of hoo-hah about Gold and Monetary Policy, but rarely about Gold and Fiscal Policy. However, a Government’s fiscal policy plays an important role in the price and movement of gold. This lesson explains how. 

What is Fiscal Policy? 

The Encyclopaedia Britannica defines Fiscal Policy as: 

measures employed by governments to stabilise the economy, specifically by manipulating the levels and allocations of taxes and government expenditures. Fiscal measures are frequently used in tandem with monetary policy to achieve certain goals. 

Put simply it is how much a government taxes and how much it spends. Let’s take the UK as an example. The following graphic from the UK OBR (Office of Budget Responsibility) nicely illustrates where the UK Government receives its income from: 

sources of of public sector receipts table 

In total, approximately £811 billion is due to be received in the fiscal year. This represents just over a third of the whole economy.  Now let’s have a look at where that money goes: 

public sector spending graph

 Spending is at a level of almost £841 billion. Therefore, there is a gap or “deficit” of £30billion. The government is spending more (£841bio) than it is taking in income (GBP911bio) in this year. The cash to cover this deficit is borrowed on the financial markets, by issuing debt securities. And this is where monetary policy comes in to play, we will come back to this soon. 

For now, let’s focus on spending. Debt interest, which is the interest the government has to pay on the debt it has previously issued is approximately £51billion. That is just the interest, i.e., the cost of borrowing.  

So, we can see now why when a government borrows a lot it would prefer to pay the lowest interest rate possible. Also, governments can refinance existing debt at lower rates as interest declines.  

And who sets interest rates? In many advanced economies, there is a separation of the government and monetary policy decisionmaking. To what degree there is actual separation is hotly debated. Obviously, there is frequently pressure from the government of the day to ensure interest rates remain as low as possible for all borrowers.  

In the UK example, which has been repeated in nearly all Western economies, the deficit has tended to become larger than in previous times. 

budget deficit since 1948 graph

This can also be illustrated in this way. 

graph of debt as a percent of national income

Basically, debt has been going up for a prolonged period of time. Why is that? Again, this is hotly debated. One potential answer is the rise of the social or welfare state. Since the 1950s, politicians have promised, and electorates have expected, significant amounts of money spent on education and healthcare. On the other side of the ledger, economic growth has not kept up to the pace to keep tax receipts sufficient to meet this expenditure. 

Additionally, spending on social security, such as pensions, has increased as healthcare has improved, and life expectancy has risen. 

Thus, according to the ONS (UK Office of National Statistics) the UK Total debt is currently: 

General government gross debt was £1,876.8 billion at the end of the financial year ending (FYE) 2020, equivalent to 84.6% of gross domestic product (GDP), and 24.6 percentage points above the reference value of 60.0% set out in the protocol on the excessive deficit procedure. 

Government debt is just accumulated deficits not yet paid off plus interest costs. It is easy to see how debt can so out of control over a long period of time. Especially when politicians’ careers are far shorter than the maturities of the debt being issued. 

Governments raise money from the tax system to spend on the promises and obligations they make to the electorate, and to their debt holders. This is fiscal policy. When fiscal policy cannot raise sufficient funds for those obligations (spending) then monetary policy comes into play. 

When Fiscal Falls Short 

Governments throughout the planet, and throughout history have a terrible record of keeping borrowing under control. Whether it is waste, unproductive projects, wars or just bad discipline or inefficient tax collection, the inability to pay all expenses via only receipts from tax is fairly rare. 

It is thus clear that when fiscal policy cannot raise the cash required, other means are utilised This is why understanding fiscal policy is so crucial to understanding what monetary policy does. 

These “other means” are essentially monetary measures. Some of these measures are borrowing from financial markets. This is an ordinary monetary policy. Others are deemed more extraordinary. Such as quantitative easing, or the central bank funding the government from its “unlimited” balance sheet. 

 

Monetary policy is discussed at greater length throughout the Goldex Academy. However, the ultimate consequence of government deficits and thus borrowing, and thus extraordinary measures such as QE all serve to devalue the currency in question, and thus increase the value of Gold. 

This is why there is such a debate now about the role of central banks, their balance sheet expansion, their extraordinary measures, their asset purchases, their lowering of interest rates to zero or even negative. Is this helping governments or creating more issues for the future? If a government can access newly printed for free, then what is the incentive to ensure fiscal discipline? 

History has shown, time and time again, when this road of fiscal deficits leads to monetary debasement Gold tends to rise. It is why investors always ensure they have a keen eye on government borrowing statistics as well as the interest rate required to borrow again. It is why investors also follow the political manifestos of political parties to see if they commit to balance the books or to spend and borrow more.  

If it is the latter, then investors will tend to decrease their allocations to that currency and protect their wealth with a further increase in their Gold holdings. 

Advanced

Lesson 1:
Lesson 1:
Gold As An Investment
Discover the unique characteristics that differentiate Gold from other commodities and has outperformed not only broad-based indices but most individual commodities too.
Lesson 1: #Advanced (5 min read)
Lesson 2:
Lesson 2:
Evolution of Monetary Policy
Monetary policy used to be a fairly conservative affair, and quite frankly a slightly underwhelming topic. In the past few decades, the main goal for most policymakers was to ensure a small increase of inflation every year, also known as price stability.
Lesson 2: #Advanced (4 min read)
Lesson 3:
Lesson 3:
News and Numbers for Gold Traders
When considering your next gold investment, there’s another significant factor to be aware of: news as a price driver. Here are the most important events any gold investor should be aware of: news as a price driver.
Lesson 3: #Advanced (3 min read)
Lesson 4:
Lesson 4:
Future Trends: How the Gold Market Could Evolve
With advancements in technology and the emergence of gold-backed products like ETFs or cryptocurrencies, the landscape for the gold market – especially as a finite resource with depletion of natural reserves – has the potential to change and shift over the next ten, twenty, or even thirty years. But what factors should be considered when thinking about how the gold market could evolve?
Lesson 4: #Advanced (3 min read)
Lesson 5:
Lesson 5:
Potential Political Catalysts for Gold to the Upside
No one can predict the future. That is especially true in financial markets and politics. However, certainty sells and there are plenty of people who sell predictions that are far too confident. When it comes to price targets for financial assets it is prudent to assess their credibility and track record.
Lesson 5: #Advanced (4 min read)
Lesson 6:
Lesson 6:
Precious Metals
We all know that gold is the most famous of the precious metals, but here we're examining the others in detail can help us understand why gold remains the most popular of this group.
Lesson 6: #Advanced (3 min read)
Lesson 7:
Lesson 7:
Gold and Space
Most current estimates claim that the amount of available Gold on Earth is somewhere between 150,000 – 250,000 tonnes. And at current rates of production, it will be a few decades or a century before this supply is extinguished. But once it has, where then? 
Lesson 7: #Advanced (4 min read)
Lesson 8:
Lesson 8:
Gold and Fiscal Policy
There is always a lot of hoo-hah about Gold and Monetary Policy, but rarely about Gold and Fiscal Policy. However, a Government’s fiscal policy plays an important role in the price and movement of gold. This lesson explains how. 
Lesson 8: #Advanced (4 min read)
Lesson 9:
Lesson 9:
Junior Gold Miners
Structured products, ETFs, ETNs and mining companies all give investors exposure to gold price movements, among other things. This lesson focuses on the small mining companies, commonly known as junior gold mining companies. 
Lesson 9: #Advanced (4 min read)
Lesson 10:
Lesson 10:
What is Universal Basic Income?
Like so many of these abstract economic terms Universal Basic Income (UBI) has a number of definitions and variants. This lesson will take you through these different ideas, continuing to a summary of both sides of this controversial policy. We will then look at what the implications could be in financial markets.
Lesson 10: #Advanced (4 min read)